Lesson 1.8 Culture
I don't understand why in,
''Excusez-moi, pouvez-vous m’aider s’il vous plaît? Excuse me, can you please help me?''.
why,in m'aider, is the verb aider still in it's neutral form.
m'aider
Hi.
"aider" in its neutral, or infinitive form means "to help". "Pouvez" is from "Pouvoir", which means "to be able to". and is followed by "-vous" to make it a question (verb and subject are inverted to form a question) so "pouvez-vous" means "are you able to.."
Hence "pouvez-vous aider" would mean "are you able to help.." or "can you help".
In the sentence "Can you help me?", "you" is the subject and "me " is the direct object.
Hence, "me" can be replaced with the direct object pronoun "me" (pronounced as MUH).
This gives you "me aider" which sounds stilted, so the "e" is dropped to give you "m'aider".
Hope this helps.
"aider" in its neutral, or infinitive form means "to help". "Pouvez" is from "Pouvoir", which means "to be able to". and is followed by "-vous" to make it a question (verb and subject are inverted to form a question) so "pouvez-vous" means "are you able to.."
Hence "pouvez-vous aider" would mean "are you able to help.." or "can you help".
In the sentence "Can you help me?", "you" is the subject and "me " is the direct object.
Hence, "me" can be replaced with the direct object pronoun "me" (pronounced as MUH).
This gives you "me aider" which sounds stilted, so the "e" is dropped to give you "m'aider".
Hope this helps.
Sorry but i don't quite understand why is it only when there and a subject and a direct object can i change it into a direct object pronoun.
I still do not understand why it is still in it's infinitive form ''aider''.
I still do not understand why it is still in it's infinitive form ''aider''.
Okay.
"aider" literally means "to help". "Pouvez-vous" means "Are you able?", hence "Pouvez-vous aider" means "Are you able to help?".
In French, you can replace direct objects with pronouns. The pronouns are:
Me/m'-me
te/t'-you
le/l'-him/it
la/l'-her/it
nous-us
vous-you
les-them.
The direct object pronoun always precedes a verb, and an infinitive if one is present.
Eg. I see Pierre. Je vois Pierre. > I see him. Je "le" vois.
I want to buy a car. Je veux acheter une voiture. > I want to buy it. Je veux l'acheter.
So in "Pouvez-vous m'aider" the "m' " is shortened for "me" meaning "me".
Therefore "Pouvez-vous m'aider" means "Are you able to help me"
Regarding the pronouns, there is an article on when to use "vous" and "tu" here.
http://www.french-linguistics.co.uk/grammar/tuandvous.shtml
"aider" literally means "to help". "Pouvez-vous" means "Are you able?", hence "Pouvez-vous aider" means "Are you able to help?".
In French, you can replace direct objects with pronouns. The pronouns are:
Me/m'-me
te/t'-you
le/l'-him/it
la/l'-her/it
nous-us
vous-you
les-them.
The direct object pronoun always precedes a verb, and an infinitive if one is present.
Eg. I see Pierre. Je vois Pierre. > I see him. Je "le" vois.
I want to buy a car. Je veux acheter une voiture. > I want to buy it. Je veux l'acheter.
So in "Pouvez-vous m'aider" the "m' " is shortened for "me" meaning "me".
Therefore "Pouvez-vous m'aider" means "Are you able to help me"
Regarding the pronouns, there is an article on when to use "vous" and "tu" here.
http://www.french-linguistics.co.uk/grammar/tuandvous.shtml
Salut,
Pascal P you are absolutely correct. "M'" is the direct object pronoun for the verb 'aider'.
Andrew, try thinking about it in terms of English. We also wouldn't conjugate 'help' when making this kind of sentence.
In English, it's easiest to talk about using 'he', so let's switch to using the third person: 'Can he help me?'
If you were to conjugate 'help' to the third person singular in English, it would be 'helps', but as you see in this question, it doesn't have that 's' and stays in the infinitive no matter who the direct object is - just like in the French!
I hope this helps explain. If you're still having trouble, try emailing our tech support team at support@rocketlanguages.com - they may be able to help further.
Merci,
Marie-Claire
Pascal P you are absolutely correct. "M'" is the direct object pronoun for the verb 'aider'.
Andrew, try thinking about it in terms of English. We also wouldn't conjugate 'help' when making this kind of sentence.
In English, it's easiest to talk about using 'he', so let's switch to using the third person: 'Can he help me?'
If you were to conjugate 'help' to the third person singular in English, it would be 'helps', but as you see in this question, it doesn't have that 's' and stays in the infinitive no matter who the direct object is - just like in the French!
I hope this helps explain. If you're still having trouble, try emailing our tech support team at support@rocketlanguages.com - they may be able to help further.
Merci,
Marie-Claire
Pouvez-vous m'aider" is formal
My friends prefer informal words.
can i say
Peux- tu m'aider??
I prefer to say
Merci pour votre aide. ( but it is formal too)
Sorry, I'm very comfused
My friends prefer informal words.
can i say
Peux- tu m'aider??
I prefer to say
Merci pour votre aide. ( but it is formal too)
Sorry, I'm very comfused
@ Sami Zaki
Yes, informally you could use "Peux-tu m'aider", though I think"Est-ce que tu peux m'aider" sounds nicer.
Or you could be commanding and say "Aide-moi svp!"
You could say "merci pour toute l'aide", for "thanks for all your help".
Yes, informally you could use "Peux-tu m'aider", though I think"Est-ce que tu peux m'aider" sounds nicer.
Or you could be commanding and say "Aide-moi svp!"
You could say "merci pour toute l'aide", for "thanks for all your help".
Merci pour toute l'aide.
à bientôt
à bientôt
Merci beaucoup Pascal - these are great explanations.
A bientot
Marie-Claire
A bientot
Marie-Claire
How can I say??
Your answer is very useful. I appreciate your help.
Thank you
Your answer is very useful. I appreciate your help.
Thank you
Total posts 14727 •
Total topics 3503 •
Total members 19056 •
Our newest member Hassan A2
Try Rocket French for Free
Sign up for your Free, No-obligation Trial
and see how well Rocket French works for you!
No Credit Card Required
YES! I want to try Rocket French for free!
This is a private and fully protected mailing list.
You can unsubscribe at any time.
You can review our
Privacy Policy here.
That's right, sign up now and you'll be able to see just how well my Rocket French Premium course works for you!
Your free trial gives you instant online access to a selection of Rocket French Premium interactive audio lessons and French language and culture lessons.
You'll be amazed at how much French you know after just a few days!
4.5 out of 5
"Rocket Languages is
our Editors' Choice for
language-learning"
PC MAG
Yours sincerely,
Marie-Claire Rivière
Rocket French
