word order

Mike-9

Mike-9

September 12, 2008

An email from a German friend in Germany had a sentence written . . . "das bin aber nicht ich". Why is "aber" stuck in the middle? How does this fit in the TMP rule? Why "ich" instead of "mich"?
(deleted)

(deleted)

September 14, 2008

Hi there, the word order in German sentences can change if you want to put more emphasis on a certain word. Here in this case your friend stresses the fact that "this is not him". I don't know the context so it's hard to tell why he stresses that fact. The word "aber" is often placed in sentences like this to stress the "nicht", however in English you would'nt translate it. Your friend is the subject of this sentence, so he refers to himself as "ich". Here are some similar examples where you use "aber" in German. Please note that these are replies to a question or replies to a behaviour: "Das darfst du aber nicht machen" - You are not allowed to do this "Am Montag habe ich aber keine Zeit" - On Monday I don't have time. I hope that helps.

Want to post a comment? Just sign up for a free Rocket Languages trial

Select one of the languages below and sign up in 60 seconds. Join our user forum and experience Rocket Languages for yourself!

Let's get you talking in German.

We love German people and German culture - from magical Christmas markets and hearty dishes to fairy-tale castles and gorgeous mountain trails! And there's no better way to connect with them than by learning Deutsch.

No credit card required

or