ことが and ことは

KayronThu, 06 Jan 2011 11:52:24 -0600
みんなさん、こんにちは!

I recently listened to lesson 3.2, and I have a grammar question - when/why does the phrase ことが become ことは? The sentence it was used in is as follows:
Question: おさけをのんだことがありますか?
Reply: いいえ, おさけをのんだことはありません。おいしいですか?

Why does this change happen? Is it because it's a (negative) answer to a question?
Also, about adjectives+くて - if I understood correctly, that suffix is added when you're using more than one adjective in a sentence.

ありがとうございます。
ーカイロン
Pascal PThu, 06 Jan 2011 23:54:57 -0600
Basically, yes, the "wa" in the second case shows contrast, and, generally, in a negative sentence, "ga" can change to "wa".

In the first sentence, the "ga" is used to mark the subject, being the "drinking" of the sake. However, the emphasis is on the implied "Anata wa", as in:

As for YOU, have ever drank sake?

In the reply, the "ga" changes to "wa" to place the emphasis on the "drinking", ie.

No, (I) have never DRANK sake.

This implies that the responding person may have had prior knowledge about sake, but has never actually, drank sake.

The "wa" is contrastive. For example, Kutsu o kaimasu > Kutsu wa kaimasen.

General Idea: when "ga" is present in a negative sentence, change it to "wa".

Yes, -kute is used when listing adjectives. The usage in the lesson, atatakaku te mo
tsumetaku te mo... Also uses the mo...mo.. construction which is used to mean both or either.

So its: both warm and cool/ either warm or cool.

It can also be used with nouns.
Eg. Sakuya-san wa, sushi mo tenpura mo suki da ne? Ms. Sakuya likes both sushi and tempura doesn't she?

Note, the loss of the "ga" in "ga suki da", since the double particle "mo ga" doesn't exist.
KayronFri, 07 Jan 2011 10:27:05 -0600
Pascal,
Thanks for the detailed explanation. It all seems much clearer now. I really wish the course would put more emphasis on these little grammar points (which they might have in the grammar section, didn't get there yet)...

Kayron
Total posts 14729 • Total topics 3503 • Total members 19071 • Our newest member Peg F

Try Rocket Japanese for Free

Sign up for your Free, No-obligation Trial
and see how well Rocket Japanese works for you!
No Credit Card Required

YES! I want to try Rocket Japanese for free!



This is a private and fully protected mailing list. You can unsubscribe at any time.
You can review our Privacy Policy here.

That's right, sign up now and you'll be able to see just how well my Rocket Japanese Premium course works for you!

Your free trial gives you instant online access to a selection of Rocket Japanese Premium interactive audio lessons and Japanese language and culture lessons.

You'll be amazed at how much Japanese you know after just a few days!

4.5 out of 5

"Rocket Languages is
our Editors' Choice for
language-learning"

PC MAG

Yours sincerely,

Sayaka Matsuura

Sayaka Matsuura
Rocket Japanese

05-24-12 As seen in The New York Times, PC Mag Editors' Choice, Trust Guard - Security Verified, Better Business Bureau, 60 Day - Money back Guarantee Better Business Bureau Trust Guard - Security Verified
Libros Media Ltd - Copyright 2004-2012 | support@rocketlanguages.com
USA: 8721 Santa Monica Blvd #1229, Los Angeles, CA 90069-4057, USA | Phone: +1-310-862-1460
Asia/Pacific: 2-1008 Ferry Road, Woolston, Christchurch 8023, New Zealand | Phone: +64-3-384-6350