when to use "a" with que vas

Paul RMon, 07 Mar 2011 15:18:44 -0600
In the conversations on travel there is the phrase: Que vas a hacer?
When I speak to my Spanish friends they say that they do not use the "a". Instead they leave out the "a" and say Que vas hacer?
In other parts of the conversation on travel the phrase Que vas a tomar el sol ? is used and the "a" is spoken.My Spanish friends agree that in such a situation the "a" is used and pronounced.
Can someone explain this
Thanks
nohabloSun, 13 Mar 2011 21:57:29 -0500
This is just a wild guess, but my guess is that your Spanish friends are wrong about "¿Qué vas a hacer?" They think there's no "a" because they don't pronounce the a when what follows it is another "a" sound. The two get merged into something that definitely sounds like "¿Qué vas hacer?" However, if they were writing Spanish instead of speaking it, and if they were well educated, they would include the "a" because it's supposed to be there. I'm not 100% sure of this, but it's my guess. It's not all that different from an English speaker saying "gonna do" but writing "going to do."

As for "Que vas a tomar el sol," I don't understand that sentence. What does it mean?
nohabloMon, 14 Mar 2011 01:05:07 -0500
I was looking for information about something else when I came upon two sources that confirmed that what I said in my previous message about "¿Qué vas a hacer?" is correct. One source was a website for learning Spanish. One of the sentences that the instructor provided was "Vas a hacer la tarea esta noche" (You're going to do the homework tonight). The other confirmation comes from one of the grammar books I like best: ¡Búscalo! A Quick Reference Guide to Spanish Grammar and Usage. On p. 101 of the paperback version, the authors say clearly "When a form of ir is followed by an infinitive, "a" is required before the infinitive." The first example they give to illustrate this is ¿Qué vas a hacer?

So it seems to me pretty clear that your Spanish friends are either poorly educated (i.e., they don't know how to write correctly in Spanish) or simply weren't thinking clearly.
Total posts 14729 • Total topics 3503 • Total members 19075 • Our newest member Rima

Try Rocket Spanish for Free

Sign up for your Free, No-obligation Trial
and see how well Rocket Spanish works for you!
No Credit Card Required

YES! I want to try Rocket Spanish for free!



This is a private and fully protected mailing list. You can unsubscribe at any time.
You can review our Privacy Policy here.

That's right, sign up now and you'll be able to see just how well my Rocket Spanish Premium course works for you!

Your free trial gives you instant online access to a selection of Rocket Spanish Premium interactive audio lessons and Spanish language and culture lessons.

You'll be amazed at how much Spanish you know after just a few days!

4.5 out of 5

"Rocket Languages is
our Editors' Choice for
language-learning"

PC MAG

Yours sincerely,

Mauricio Evlampieff

Mauricio Evlampieff
Rocket Spanish

05-24-12 As seen in The New York Times, PC Mag Editors' Choice, Trust Guard - Security Verified, Better Business Bureau, 60 Day - Money back Guarantee Better Business Bureau Trust Guard - Security Verified
Libros Media Ltd - Copyright 2004-2012 | support@rocketlanguages.com
USA: 8721 Santa Monica Blvd #1229, Los Angeles, CA 90069-4057, USA | Phone: +1-310-862-1460
Asia/Pacific: 2-1008 Ferry Road, Woolston, Christchurch 8023, New Zealand | Phone: +64-3-384-6350