Forum Rocket Italian Italian Grammar Is there a "come vai?"or just "come va?"

Is there a "come vai?"or just "come va?"

jrdevivo

jrdevivo

December 20, 2016

I'm doing lesson 8.2 and I noticed that Robert says "Come va" to Maria at the beginning of the dialogue.  The "tu" form is used throughout the dialogue so I wondered why it was "Come va" instead of "Come vai."  I googled "come vai" and it doesn't seem to mean "how are you?"   Does "come va" cover formal and informal 2nd person?  Is it just a peculiarity or did I miss something?

Thanks,

Jay
Lucia - Rocket Languages Tutor

Lucia - Rocket Languages Tutor

December 20, 2016

Hi Jay,

Come va? literally means how's it going?, while come vai can be translated as how do you go [...]?

Come vai a scuola?
How do you go to school? (by car, on foot...)
Incidentally this sentence can also be translated as How's school?, "How do you go at school", meaning your grades etc.

Va belongs to the third person singular, vai to the second one. The conjugations for the third singular person are used for the formal You as well:

Come va al lavoro?
How do You [formal, singular] go to work? 
How does he/she go to work?

When asking How are you, you can either say Come va? (both formal and informal) or Come stai? (informal), come sta? (formal). The latter literally translates how are you?.

Hope this helps!

Lucia
jrdevivo

jrdevivo

December 20, 2016

Hi Lucia,

I completely forgot the literal translation.  I'm so lost trying to figure out pronouns, I'm forgetting things from lesson 1.1 as well!   Thank you much!  

Jay
Lucia - Rocket Languages Tutor

Lucia - Rocket Languages Tutor

December 21, 2016

Welcome. Keep up the good work!

Want to post a comment? Just sign up for a free Rocket Languages trial

Select one of the languages below and sign up in 60 seconds. Join our user forum and experience Rocket Languages for yourself!

Let's get you talking in Italian.

We love Italian people and Italian culture - from ancient amphitheaters and sunny vineyards to delicious pastas and captivating music! And there's no better way to connect with them than by learning l'italiano.

No credit card required

or