17.9 Singular and Plural Words

Muchen7092

February 19, 2019

A section in 17.9 begins with: "Then you have some where the noun seems singular in English but you use the plural to form the verb:"

But hat follows are a series of examples where just the opposite it true. Example:

Die Umgebung ist sehr ruhig.

The surroundings are very quiet.

sfpugh

February 20, 2019

Yes you are right, they do seem to have it the wrong way round.
For me the tricky one is:

Wir sind das Volk.

We are the people.

The English is straight forward, "we" and "people" are both plural, but "das Volk" looks like singular but "we" is plural.
I wonder what the rules are when you use sein like this.
I suppose in English you could say "we are a nation "

Apparently Wir sind das Volk was a political slogan.

Muchen7092

February 20, 2019

Thought of this:

"We Are The World" - Sung by Michael Jackson, Tina Turner, Stevie Wonder, Diana Ross, Lionel Richie and Ray Charles

sfpugh

February 20, 2019

Language is a funny thing, I suppose the words nation, world and Das Volk all have a kind of implied plural in them. They all sound a bit like a slogans when combined with "we are ..." :-)

On the other hand you could say "We are a People" making a plural word singular.

17.9 Singular and Plural Words

Ask a question or post a response