Forum Rocket German German Grammar why ist es instead of es ist

why ist es instead of es ist



In lesson 2.1 Die Touristeninformation
​Why do we say  ist es instead of es ist. "Ja, aber heute ist es geschlossen" instead of "Ja, aber heute es ist geschlossen" 

David K

David K

I'm  only a fellow student, but I believe the answer is that in German sentences the verb is always in the second position.

So if the sentence were just "es ist geschlossen" the word order would be as you expect, however, when adding the "Ja, aber heute .. which occupies the "first position" the verb "ist" must come next. 

Scan through the topic headings for the lessons on word order.

The curious thing though is that With "Ja, aber" it seems to me that the "heute" should be kicked to a later position like for example, "Ja, aber ist es heute Geschlossen."

My only guess is that Maybe Ja, doesn't count for some reason?

Let's hope an expert helps us out soon.

Ask a question or post a response

If you want to ask a question or post a response you need to be a member.

If you are already a member login here.
If you are not a member you can become one by taking the free Rocket German trial here.