I have seen this sentence a couple of times “Wie geht es dir / Ihnen”. One thing I am wondering about is why we are using dative case. I assume it is because you are addressing someone directly?
Wie geht es dir / ihnen

RexV
April 11, 2019

sfpugh
April 12, 2019
I think you can see what is going on if you translate the phrase literally.
Wie geht es dir
How goes it with you.
But it is usually translated as "how are you"
Wie geht es dir
How goes it with you.
But it is usually translated as "how are you"

RexV
April 13, 2019
Hi again,
I understand what it means but it is more why we are using "dir/ihnen" and not "dich/sie".
Thanks beforehand
I understand what it means but it is more why we are using "dir/ihnen" and not "dich/sie".
Thanks beforehand

sfpugh
April 13, 2019
I thought that "with you" would make it clear.
The phrase uses an impersonal construction with es as a dummy subject.
gehen is an intransitive verb with can't take a direct object you have to use dir not dich.
You can look up intransitive verbs.
The phrase uses an impersonal construction with es as a dummy subject.
gehen is an intransitive verb with can't take a direct object you have to use dir not dich.
You can look up intransitive verbs.

Liss-Rocket-Languages-Tutor
April 16, 2019
Hallo RexV und sfpugh!
Exactly as sfpugh points out, Wie geht es dir/Ihnen? (careful of the capital "I" there) doesn't actually translate literally to "How are you?" Instead, it translates to "How goes it with you?" Because we have the meaning "with you" instead of just "you," we use the dative forms (dir/Ihnen) instead of the accusative (dich/Sie).
If you're still not sure why the addition of "with" (or of other prepositions, such as "to") means that we need to use the dative, the lesson on the dative in Module 6 of Level 1 should be helpful.
Tschüss!
Liss
Exactly as sfpugh points out, Wie geht es dir/Ihnen? (careful of the capital "I" there) doesn't actually translate literally to "How are you?" Instead, it translates to "How goes it with you?" Because we have the meaning "with you" instead of just "you," we use the dative forms (dir/Ihnen) instead of the accusative (dich/Sie).
If you're still not sure why the addition of "with" (or of other prepositions, such as "to") means that we need to use the dative, the lesson on the dative in Module 6 of Level 1 should be helpful.
Tschüss!
Liss